I’m a fan of cake in general, but the queen of all cakes for me is the mud cake. It’s just not a birthday celebration unless I have a mud cake, and so it was, this birthday too.
The difference was, that this year, I decided to make myself a mud cake. How hard could it be?
Despite having eaten mud cake for the past 20+ years of my life, I really wasn’t exactly sure how it was made. You have to be very careful when you’re buying a mud cake, that the cake maker knows what a mud cake is. It’s supposed to be heavy, thick, chocolatey and decadent. Many bought mud cakes are too oily, too spongy and have a weird taste. Horror of horrors is, when I ask the waiter at a restaurant if the dessert mud cake is truly a mud cake, and I’m served a plain chocolate cake! Sacre bleu! The best mud cake I’ve ever found is from The Cheesecake Shop. They really make outstanding cakes all around. However, I digress from my own cake making adventure. Well, after some searching on the net, I settled on a simple recipe, that didn’t use ganache or chopped chocolate. It was simply flour, cocoa, sugar, butter and eggs. My first attempt wasn’t as muddy as I’d like as I had a few oven issues and had to cook it a little longer than I would have liked. It was still nice, but could have been a lot better. Anyway, I’ve modified that original recipe slightly, made it again this weekend and it was fabulous! This is a cake you probably shouldn’t eat very often… here’s the recipe… While there is no reprieve from the badness of cakes, you can make them slightly healthier by using wholemeal flour and raw sugars. CSR make a raw caster sugar now, which means it’s less processed and while not exactly good for you, it’s not as bad as the bleached white stuff.

The Queen of Cakes, a rich chocolate mud cake
The cake:
1 cup butter – room temperature (1 x 125 gm stick of butter)
2 cups raw caster sugar (egads! it’s a lot!)
4 eggs (free range of course! – poor little chickens who aren’t free range lead terrible lives)
1 1/2 cups of wholemeal plain flour
1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
Icing:
1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa (or more, depending on your chocolate tooth)
3 cups icing sugar (not the mix, but plain old icing sugar)
1/2 cup melted butter (half a 125gm stick of butter)
4-5 tablsepoons skim milk (ha ha!)
Cake directions:
Preheat oven to 180 degrees.
Line a 26cm or 10 inch tin with greased paper in preparation for your cake batter. Sift the flour and cocoa together into a bowl.
In another larger bowl, mix the butter and sugar together so it’s all combined and like a buttery sugary spread.
Add each egg separately, making sure you mix one in before adding the next.
Grab your flour and cocoa mix and fold it in with the butter, sugar and egg mixture (add the flour/cocoa to the butter bowl mix).
You can be quite rough with mixing as it’s a mud cake, and you don’t have to worry about its light texture being spoiled from too much working of the batter. Make sure you mix it thoroughly so it forms a smooth, even chocolatey batter.
Place the batter into your lined tin and spread it out evenly. Use your fingers if you have to as it might be a bit thick.
Cookin in a medium oven (180 deg Celcius or 350 F) for 25-35 minutes. Cake will be cooked when a cake tester, pin, fork, or skewer comes out clean. Be careful in the last 10 minutes and check your cake often. The line between a raw cake and overcooked cake is sometimes only a matter of seconds.
Icing directions:
Sift/combine the cocoa and icing sugar ensuring no lumps.
Stir in melted butter.
Add milk as necessary (try a spoon, stir it in, then try another one etc) to make a thick but spreadable consistency.
Once your cake is cooked, let it sit in the tin for 10 minutes, then turn it out onto a cooling rack, removing the paper. Let it cool for another 5 or so minutes. The icing is meant to go on a warm cake, so that it melts slightly. I find that this recipe gives you plenty of icing, so you can go for lashings of it. Make sure your cake isn’t too warm, or the icing will melt completely and separate. Do a small test patch.
Using this recipe and cake tin size will make a cake about 4-5 cm tall.